In short: Destruction minutes document the work of a licensed facility. On the standard tax route, the valuation commission issues a separate decision. For its pharmaceutical services, Scrap coordinates applications, collects the minutes and delivers the file to the customer.
Accounting needs a document to write stock off, and then the tax office asks for that document. As a result, many companies complete the disposal but leave the minutes incomplete. This article explains how destruction minutes come about, who issues each document, and which lines the minutes should carry. For the wider tax picture, see our guide to lost goods and the disposal process.
The facility’s minutes also form part of the file for food and beverage stock.
Who issues the destruction minutes?
The licensed facility issues the destruction minutes covered in this guide. The notary’s destruction determination minutes are a separate document. Scrap does not issue the facility’s minutes. Instead, we collect them from the facility, check them, and hand them to you. The verification documents come from the relevant authority: a notary, an expert, a valuation committee, or a health directorate. Pre-destruction inspection records document the condition of the goods, and the notary’s separate minutes record what the notary witnessed during destruction. The minutes prove the destruction itself. Neither replaces the other. If a required document is missing, your stock write-off is harder to prove.
So one file holds several documents, and each has a different owner. Therefore, our job is to set their order and track the required documents.
Who issues each document in the destruction minutes file?
The facility issues its destruction minutes. The authorities and the expert issue the inspection records. The valuation commission issues its decision. The valuation commission is the body that inspects goods and determines their arm’s-length value for tax purposes. In fact, several of these documents appear together in Scrap’s standard pharmaceutical file.
| Document | Who issues it? | What does it do? | What does Scrap do? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Facility destruction minutes | Licensed facility | Document the facility’s work. | Collects them and submits them to the relevant authorities. |
| Expert report | Expert | Documents the inspection before destruction. | Files the application, attends the inspection and collects the report. |
| Medicine or medical device inspection record | Health directorate’s pharmacy or medical device unit | Documents the inspection of medicines or medical devices before processing. | Applies, attends the inspection and gives the unit the facility minutes. |
| Notarial inspection minutes | Notary | Separately document the notary’s inspection. | Coordinates the notary step and adds the minutes to the file. |
| Valuation commission decision | Valuation commission | Sets the benchmark value of destroyed stock. | Applies, attends the inspection and obtains the decision after processing. |
| Application to destroy goods at customs | Customs broker on behalf of the customer | Submits the application to customs. | Coordinates the destruction and recycling work. |
| VAT petition | Scrap drafts it. The customer stamps and signs it. | Notifies the tax office of the VAT declaration on line 507. | Submits the signed petition to the customer’s tax office. |
You and your financial advisor choose the tax procedure. The goods, their loss in value and your tax goal guide that choice. Scrap then handles the applications and paperwork accordingly. If you do not seek a tax advantage, the supervision of a single official may be enough, and the process can be shorter.
What do the notary, expert and valuation commission do in the tax file?
On the standard route, the valuation commission inspects the goods and determines their arm’s-length value. Notary minutes and expert reports also support the same file where needed. Article 278 of the Tax Procedure Law covers goods that lose much of their value through spoilage or breakage. It values them at arm’s-length value. If the methods in Article 267 cannot set that value, the valuation commission assesses it on application. You can challenge the valuation in the tax court. However, filing a lawsuit does not stop assessment or collection of the tax.
Article 278/A opens another path for taxpayers whose disposal operations are continuous. The Revenue Administration reviews the application and sets a product-specific disposal rate. As a result, the comparable price of goods destroyed up to that rate counts as zero. We explain the conditions in our disposal rate roadmap.
How is medicine destroyed, and who keeps the pharmaceutical destruction minutes?
In the standard pharmaceutical process, a licensed facility carries out the work after the official inspections. The customer, health directorate and tax office each receive the facility’s minutes. For medicines, the district health directorate joins the process. In the flow Scrap applies, we first file the applications with the valuation commission, the expert, and the district health directorate. When the official bodies count and inspect the goods, the Scrap team accompanies them and records the work in photos and video. Once the expert issues the report, we book the facility and arrange transport. Then a notary attends on the destruction day. The facility destroys the medicine and issues the destruction minutes. Finally, the notary prepares the destruction determination minutes.
On the standard pharmaceutical route, copies of the facility’s destruction minutes go to three places. Specifically, we give one copy to the district health directorate’s pharmacy unit and one to the tax office. In addition, one copy stays in your file. For medical devices, Scrap gives a copy of the facility’s minutes to the health directorate’s medical device unit. You can read more in pharmaceutical waste harm and proper disposal processes. Recalls of defective products follow a separate process.
The notary’s minutes go into the file as a separate document. See the expired medicines guide for the application and dispatch sequence.
Which lines should destruction minutes contain?
Facility destruction minutes include the date, waste code and description, quantity, dispatch note number and the facility’s statement of what it did. The lines below are our own practice. We check these details in the minutes and the supporting records:
- Date and place: the day of destruction and the facility’s address.
- Facility name: the licensed facility that did the destruction.
- Goods: the waste description and weight (kg) in the facility’s minutes; the product type, batch, and expiry date in the product list and inspection records.
- Weighing: the result from the facility’s scale.
- Method and waste code: incineration, recovery, or another process, and the six-digit code. The waste owner or an environmental engineer sets the code.
- Verification reference: the date and number of the notary, expert, committee, or health directorate document.
- Signatures: the name, title, and signature of those who sign.
- Record reference: the photos, video, and dispatch notes.
Then we compare the minutes and their attachments with the product list you sent. Matching quantities is one part of the check. If they do not match, we clear the difference with the facility before handover. A copy of the minutes should also sit with your accounting team, because it helps reconcile quantities. The destruction date, date of notification and expense period can differ.
How do destruction minutes reach the tax office?
On the standard valuation commission route, we submit the facility’s destruction minutes and inspection documents to the tax office after the facility completes the work. We then collect the valuation commission decision. Under Article 8 of General Communiqué No. 496, the expense belongs to the period in which the valuation commission decision, or the minutes named in the Communiqué, are served.
Scrap drafts the VAT notification letter. The customer stamps and signs it, and Scrap delivers it to the customer’s tax office. The letter states that VAT on goods covered by the valuation commission decision will be reported under code 507, “Lost Goods”, in the No. 1 VAT return for the relevant period. The customer and their financial advisor file the return.
Similarly, taxpayers using Article 278/A keep the destruction records and documents required by that procedure and produce them on request.
On VAT, the tax administration’s view is that destroyed goods count as lost goods, so you cannot deduct the VAT on them. However, the Council of State has ruled differently in a decision on destroyed medicines. We explain this split in VAT on destroyed goods. For this reason, departing from the administration’s practice carries a risk of dispute. Review your case with your financial advisor and legal counsel.
What does Scrap do in the destruction minutes process?
First, we take your product list and file the inspection request under the procedure you chose. On the standard pharmaceutical route, we accompany the inspection and collect the expert report. We book the destruction day with the facility and arrange transport. Scrap sends the customer the product and disposal facility details. The customer issues the dispatch note, and Scrap follows up until it is ready. We secure the pallets with Scrap security tape and seal the loaded vehicle with a serial-numbered Scrap seal. The carrier takes it to the facility sealed. At the facility, Scrap opens the seal, watches and records unloading and processing in photos and video, then collects the facility’s minutes. We check the minutes and hand them to you. That leaves you with your own approval and your accounting entry.
You find all documents in the Online Tracking System. It also shows which step is done and who did what. You can download the minutes, verification documents, and reports at any time. One consultant runs the whole destruction and recycling process. It closes in a single file.
Under Service Providers, the Online Tracking System shows current facility and carrier permits and licences. It also lists the facility’s quality certificate, its MoTAT (Mobile Waste Tracking System) number, and vehicle and driver records. In addition, at the end of every destruction and recycling process, Scrap gives the customer a Sustainable Transformation Report describing the outcome. See the licensed disposal company checklist for how to check the scope of a facility’s licence.
If you have stock to destroy, fill in the request form, so we can prepare a destruction and recycling quote from your list.
Frequently asked questions
What are pharmaceutical destruction minutes?
Pharmaceutical destruction minutes document the work of the licensed facility. In its standard pharmaceutical process, Scrap gives the facility minutes to the relevant authorities and provides a copy to the customer. The notary issues separate minutes.
How is medicine destroyed?
Under Scrap’s standard tax procedure, officials inspect the medicines and an expert issues a report. A licensed facility then processes the goods, and Scrap submits the facility minutes and obtains the commission decision. The process can be shorter when the customer does not seek the tax treatment.
Is a notary mandatory for destruction minutes?
The facility issues its own destruction minutes. Whether you need a notary depends on the procedure and documents required. You choose the tax procedure with your accountant, and Scrap handles the paperwork accordingly.
Why does the tax office ask for destruction minutes?
Because the document shows that the goods written off were actually destroyed. Article 278/A of the Tax Procedure Law requires taxpayers using that procedure to keep every disposal record and document and to produce them when asked.
Is there a ready template for destruction minutes?
We do not publish a downloadable template at the moment. The facility issues the minutes, and we check their lines. The line list in the article is our practice, not one mandatory format.
Who signs the destruction minutes?
The facility issues its own destruction minutes, and its officials sign. A notary, expert, committee, or health directorate issues the verification documents. In each file, we check the signing authority with the body that issued the document.
Sources
- Tax Procedure Law No. 213, Articles 267, 278, and 278/A
- Tax Procedure Law General Communiqué (Serial No. 496, Official Gazette, 25 May 2018, No. 30431)
- Regulation on Waste Management (Official Gazette, 2 April 2015, No. 29314), Articles 5, 10, and 12
- VAT General Implementation Communiqué, Section III/C-2.4 (the administration’s view on lost goods; see our VAT article)
This article is general information and does not replace legal or tax advice. The flow described is Scrap’s practice. Consult your financial advisor before a specific disposal.
İmha Sürecinizi Planlayalım
Vergi avantajı takvimi ve imha süreciniz hakkında ücretsiz danışmanlık alın.
